The Indian cricket team's selection strategy has come under intense scrutiny following the exclusion of left-arm pacer Arshdeep Singh from the playing XI for the first two One Day Internationals against New Zealand in January 2026. Former India batter Mohammad Kaif explicitly questioned the team management's decision, particularly the inclusion of fast bowler Prasidh Krishna, remarking that Krishna "always goes for runs except in a game or two." Kaif urged head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Shubman Gill to consider Arshdeep, a proven wicket-taker, for the series decider. Echoing similar sentiments, veteran spinner R Ashwin passionately defended Arshdeep Singh, criticizing the Gambhir-led management for benching a player with a strong white-ball record. Ashwin highlighted that such omissions can erode a bowler's rhythm and confidence, drawing parallels from his own career. He emphasized that Arshdeep has consistently performed when given the opportunity and deserves a secure place in the playing XI. Arshdeep Singh had recently performed well in the ODI series against South Africa, emerging as India's most economical bowler with five wickets. The controversy intensified as India opted for Mohammed Siraj, Harshit Rana, and Prasidh Krishna as their specialist pacers in the initial ODIs against New Zealand. Fans and former cricketers alike expressed outrage, questioning the rationale behind overlooking Arshdeep despite his strong recent form and his vital role in India's T20 World Cup 2024 triumph. The debate underscores broader concerns about bowler rotation policies and the importance of player confidence in international cricket.