Indian cricket is grappling with the performance of young all-rounder Nitish Kumar Reddy, as assistant coach Ryan ten Doeschate publicly voiced concerns about his inability to capitalize on opportunities. Following India's seven-wicket defeat to New Zealand in the second One Day International in Rajkot, Doeschate remarked that Reddy "often ends up not doing a heck of a lot in the games" despite being given game time. In the match, Reddy contributed 20 runs off 21 balls and bowled two wicketless overs, conceding 13 runs. This performance, along with his overall international white-ball record of seven appearances since October 2024, has led to questions about his suitability for a consistent role in the team, a sentiment encapsulated by the article's "square peg in a round hole" analogy. Hindustan Times points out that Reddy's initial Test selection in November 2024 for the Australia tour was a "left-field choice" based on potential rather than compelling statistics. The coach also addressed Captain Rohit Sharma's form, stating he is "short on cricket" despite recent participation in domestic tournaments, which has impacted his fluency at the crease. Sharma scored 26 runs in the first ODI and 24 in the second against New Zealand, prompting discussions about his consistency. Meanwhile, former India batter Hanuma Vihari has come out in defense of Nitish Reddy, criticizing those who are quick to write off the 22-year-old all-rounder, highlighting his past performances and potential. The ongoing India vs New Zealand ODI series has brought these selection and performance challenges to the forefront, making team composition and player readiness key concerns for the Indian management as they look towards future tournaments.